Train2Game Game Designers should definitely be interested in this; League of Legends design director Tom Cadwell has been discussing the common pitfalls of game design.

“Even though we know how to do good design, we still make mistakes a lot, you can set up processes that facilitate good decisions,” he said at his GDC Online talk in Texas.

“Once you know what the right behaviours are, it’s very possible to coach your peers or subordinates. Some of these pitfalls are human flaws, and it is possible that some people don’t manage those flaws well enough even though they’re great designers.”

Cadwell discussed something Train2Game Game Designers may be particularly interested, that is the concept that an idea is ‘too awesome’ to cut from a game and how this can damage development.

“We probably shouldn’t do it, but man, it’s too awesome,” is a dangerous thought said the League of Legends Game Director.

“Now you have a problem because you’re bending over backwards to do this thing that doesn’t fit.”

But he said that even if they know the feature doesn’t work, game designers won’t want to say so in order to avoid being ‘that guy’

“Now you’re all excited… And you don’t want to be the guy who’s being a buzzkill” said Cadwell

In order to prevent this from happening, he suggests “decisions are reviewed by peers or supervisors who are not interested parties, who weren’t at the kick-off.”

Cadwell added that if something costs a lot to do, is it really worth it?

“Structure process to assess cost to risk — it takes six times the engineering resources. Is it worth it?” he added.

The talk provides interesting reading for Train2Game Game Designers, with excerpts available on Gamasutra.

Reports of GDC Online have provided Train2Game students of all disciplines with a lot of fascinating information. Just yesterday the Train2Game blog revealed what Valve had to say about the importance of testing games.

So Train2Game, what are your thoughts on Cadwell’s comments? Do you agree that things can be ‘too awesome’ to go in a game? Have you experienced it when producing games?

Leave your comments here on the Train2Game blog, or on the Train2Game forum.

[Source: Gamasutra]